Search Fishers Island Cottages

"Our floors were being refinished so we needed a place to stay for a week with our dog. The cottage was perfect for our needs, with plenty of space to walk our dog."

"I was in the area for my niece's college graduation at Wesleyan University and loved the chance to explore this beautiful part of the country. Being so close to the water in Old Saybrook was amazing, and the house itself was both fresh and cozy. The hosts were very responsive, and the only issue (which they acknowledged in advance) was that a portion of the fence was missing, due to a recent storm. That said, they were up front and apologetic, knowing that I'd booked because my dogs were along....

"Adorable cottage, nicely appointed, great location."

"A perfect weekend getaway with a breath taking lake view! Peaceful & quite. Great location short drive to many places of interest. Very clean & comfortable accommodations and wonderful communication with the host of this property. If you are looking for a lake front escape this is the place! "

"We had a great time at this wonderful cottage! Everything was clean and exactly as stated online. Our family was able to join us for our daughter’s graduation from URI and not have to worry about hotels. Thank you for help making our weekend even more memorable!"

"Great time. Nice visit. Cottage was clean, very comfortable and as advertised. Would definitely stay again."

"We went to Foxwoods for a concert and the rooms there were ridiculously priced. I ended finding this little gem on VRBO. Would highly recommend, especially for families. Kids had a blast"

"A traditional family lake cottage. Peaceful, quiet, and rented with love. Everything from the thoughtful little notes in the home to the paintings on the wall makes you feel cozy and welcomed. Everything you could need or want is provided. The hot tub under the stars, on the water is really the icing on the cake."

"The home was very nice and the location was great! Had an awesome time despite the weather!"

"Very intimate cottage setting, lovely beach scenery, walking distance to the beach, feet away from hearing the crash of the waves. Short drive to grab whatever you have forgotten or need to enhance your stay in this tiny home. Great location to unplug, energize, and bond with your family. You can create the quality time you miss out on in the world today, you will not have the distractions of television, internet, or gaming."

"I booked this for a sister weekend. It was perfect for what we needed. It appears that the house was built to be a summer getaway, so it is pretty basic and no frills and comes with all the creaks and quicks of an older house. The living room is perfect for hanging out and the four chairs make it easy to rearrange to suit your needs. The kitchen is nicely stocked with everything you would need to stay with a family and the dining room is spacious enough to easily accommodate everyone staying...

"This cottage is so adorable and just a short walk to the beach and a local convenience store. This makes it easy to park the car and just walk to get coffee and such. We stayed in October so not much open this time of year, but we were in the area for a family wedding so not much time to hang out anyway. This was the first time I've rented on Vrbo, so I wasn't sure what to expect as have read a lot about obnoxious owners with tons of rules, but Brett is super-chill with only a couple of things...

"The tree outfront needs to be trimmed desperately. Turning out of the house was quite dangerous. The house was cute and old. It was a 15-20 minute drive to all nearby attractions."

"The cottage was absolutely perfect for myself and my elderly Doxie Rosie. We went RI to visit a friend and needed a place to stay. It was immaculate, great location, private and was well stocked w/all necessary needs. It was just the 2 of us but would also be perfect for a small family. I highly recommend it. Great cottage."

"I needed to book a place for my family to stay when I had them over for Thanksgiving dinner. The 50s cottage was clean and adorable. Comfortable as well. We did have a hard time figuring out the door code system. (It may have been us old folks) Other than that everything was great!"

"Very sweet cottage and perfect place to stay while taking our kids home from uri"

"Pleasant !"

"My extended family and I had a delightful week at Paul's place on Misquamicut beach. The house and grounds were super-clean and ready when we arrived, and the house was well-stocked with cooking, linen, entertainment, and beach supplies! The location is just superb -- just a few sandy steps from the waves! And the view from the back patio was mesmerizing. We had a wonderful mostly sunny week, and so the portable pop-up shade canopy that we brought and set up above the picnic table was a...

"My friends and I had a great time staying at this adorable cottage! The beach is so close and the parking pass is a lifesaver! We also loved making a fire and relaxing in the backyard. There was plenty of room in the kitchen to cook while spending time together. Will definitely book again!"

"Best affordable hotel in Montauk"

"It was so close to town!"

"An amazing stay with our girls!!! Can’t wait to go back!"