Search Pulteney Cottages

"Check in was very easy, I was given a code to a lockbox. I overpacked assuming it would be a little more rustic, turns out it has all the comfort and conveniences of home. Cottage, grounds, and hot tub were clean and inviting. We were there very early spring before the leaves grew on the trees and the view was incredible! There’s a nice hiking trail a mile down the road, and water access directly across the street. This place exceeded my expectations all around! Book it!"

"The single-lane access road to the cabin has several sharp bends to get to and from the location, but once you are there, it's very relaxing. Not small, but just big enough. Very clean and everything works. My wife and I enjoyed our stay. Monica was easily reachable for any questions."

"Gary’s place was just what the doctor ordered. Cozy and clean, well-stocked, and secure. Gary’s communication was fantastic - he gave a heads-up on the sneaky railroad underpass to get to the house (which was totally fine for my sedan), and checked in at the beginning and ending of my stay. Very dog friendly! My pup absolutely loved the backyard and dock, and at 11 years old, she had her first experience with using a doggie door. Great location for quiet R&R, small town exploring (Geneva and...

"Great quiet area, and the nicest owners. You cant go wrong here"

"This trip was planned as a girls getaway to surprise our daughter (who has three sons) coming up from Florida for a long weekend. We had such a fun time we decided to make it a yearly tradition. The house held all 8 of us comfortably, in a beautiful setting right on Seneca Lake, offering a beautiful display of Gods creation from either of the two decks. LOTS of laughter & love!"

"We had a wonderful stay at this home for the extended Memorial Day Weekend. The home is in a perfect spot to hit some of the area's finest wineries. The home had everything we needed to be comfortable both inside and outside. We enjoyed the sunsets, kayaks, the fire table, and the view in general. The area is very quiet and the neighbors were all welcoming and friendly. Connor was very responsive and even offered for us to check in earlier than expected - a welcome bonus after coming from a...

"I booked this place in January for our daughter’s graduation from Cornell in Ithaca about 45 minutes away because there were no hotels available, it turned out perfect, the place was super! Clean, well appointed and very peaceful. I would recommend over a cramped hotel room. Thanks"

"Open floor plan worked well for our family. The many outdoor sitting areas was a real plus."

"Clean, quiet, calm, delightful"

"After descending 73 stairs with luggage and groceries, the vacation home was a little slice of paradise. Lovely ❤️."

"The place was great. It appears to be pretty new and it was nicely decorated and well kept. The property manager answered my inquiries promptly and professionally. The only issue we had was the dirt road leading up to the property. It was a pothole ridden mess. The property manager warned me about it ahead of time but it was worse than I expected. Having said that, we were the first renters for the season (early April) and a small section of that road got repaired while we were there. I...

"Loved our stay once again. Great location and always love the outdoor spaces. Relaxing stay for sure!"

"Nice little place. Exactly what we needed as we did not spend much time there. The water is definitely as described in the listing, but it was not a surprise. Would definitely book again."

"Lovely property and amenities. Comfortable. Location was close to many sights in the Finger lakes. Enjoyed our stay."

"My family of 4, including two pre-teens, had a wonderful stay at Jess & Tom's place over Memorial Day weekend. The house is small but it is clear that a lot of thought has gone into making the most of the space -- bunk beds with built-in shelves, nice shelving and hooks in the bathroom, storage space under benches in the living room, and my kids' favorite, the boat house with TV and games. Lots of natural light makes the space feel bigger. The beds were comfortable. The best part of the house is...

"My husband and 2 adult kids stayed at this beautiful lake house! The deck and views were amazing.!! The house was equipped with everything you would think of bringing and the host was very responsive to any questions!! They made us feel very welcome!!"

"Check in was very easy, I was given a code to a lockbox. I overpacked assuming it would be a little more rustic, turns out it has all the comfort and conveniences of home. Cottage, grounds, and hot tub were clean and inviting. We were there very early spring before the leaves grew on the trees and the view was incredible! There’s a nice hiking trail a mile down the road, and water access directly across the street. This place exceeded my expectations all around! Book it!"

"Lovely stay. Cabin is adorable, clean, with a gorgeous view. Dave and Joann were very helpful as hosts and checked in to make sure we didn’t need anything."